Call 303.997.2218
Attorney Wellness Project · Briefing

Compassion Fatigue in Legal Work:
A Briefing

A prosecutor spends Tuesday morning with the autopsy photographs and Tuesday afternoon negotiating a plea. A family lawyer reads a child’s forensic interview at ten at night so she’s ready for a nine o’clock hearing, and nobody in the courtroom the next morning can tell. Lawyers get very good at not reacting, and the profession treats that as the end of the matter.

Attorneys scored higher on secondary traumatic stress than the therapists they were compared with.

The research treats this as an occupational exposure, and the damage rises with how much of the material you handle. Professions that walk into the worst of it on purpose build recovery into the job. The Army runs after-action reviews, and therapists get regular supervision. Lawyers mostly go back in the next morning with nothing, so this briefing covers what the exposure does and how people who perform under fire for a living keep it from wearing them down.

What the research on lawyers shows

Researchers compared attorneys at agencies that handle domestic violence and family law cases with mental health providers and social service workers of similar age and experience. The attorneys carried far more clients who’d been through violence or abuse (Levin and Greisberg, 2003).

Secondary traumatic stress is measured in three parts. The attorneys scored higher than both comparison groups on every one of them, and higher on burnout too (Levin and Greisberg, 2003).

IntrusionImages from the case file, the photos, or the testimony come back when you didn’t ask for them, at dinner or at 3 a.m.
AvoidanceYou start steering around certain cases, certain files, even certain streets, and you go numb to the people involved.
ArousalYour body stays on alert. You sleep badly, startle easily, and snap at people who didn’t do anything.

The authors tied the difference to that heavier caseload and to the lack of any supervision for the toll of the work, which the other two professions get as part of the job.

View through a dark wood doorway into a full conference room during a session
The people in the room see composure. They don’t see what it costs.

A study comparing criminal lawyers with lawyers in other practice areas found:

The criminal lawyers’ beliefs about their own safety and other people’s had shifted too, which is the mark of vicarious trauma described further down this page.

What composure costs
An AWP faculty member mid-conversation, leaning in and gesturing as he talks
Keeping a poker face makes you remember less of what you saw.

Researchers showed people photos of injured people. The ones told to keep a poker face remembered less of what they’d seen when asked to describe it afterward. The ones told to look at the photos the way a clinician would, focusing on what each image showed, remembered just as much as people given no instructions at all (Richards and Gross, 2000). For a lawyer who has to work from those details, how you look at the evidence matters.

Hiding a reaction doesn’t switch it off, either. When people were asked to keep their faces still during a disturbing film, other measures showed the body’s stress system working harder, and they felt every bit as bad as the people who hid nothing (Gross and Levenson, 1993).

The stress your body takes longest to shake comes from being judged when the outcome isn’t yours to control.

Researchers pooled 208 laboratory experiments that measured cortisol, the body’s main stress hormone, in people put under pressure, such as giving a speech to a panel grading it. The tasks that raised cortisol the most, and kept it up longest afterward, were the ones where someone was evaluating the person and the person couldn’t control how it turned out (Dickerson and Kemeny, 2004). A contested hearing works that way for hours at a time.

Dr. Kemia Sarraf teaching a full ballroom of professionals
Most of it never shows up at work. It shows up at home, at 3 a.m.
How it shows up
What colleagues may notice
  • Irritability or anger that isn’t like them
  • More errors, or work product that slips
  • Pulling back from colleagues and shared work
  • Trouble with clients, or ducking the hardest matters
  • Fixating on procedural details as a way to stay away from the substance
  • A sudden change of practice area or job with no clear reason
  • Rigid, inflexible handling of cases
  • Blaming clients, opposing counsel, or colleagues
What usually only you know
  • Broken sleep, or dreams about the case
  • Images from depositions, crime scene photos, or testimony that come back on their own
  • Being easily startled, or always scanning for the next problem
  • Racing thoughts, and trouble focusing on anything outside work
  • Feeling numb or far away from family and friends
  • Losing the sense that the work means anything
  • Leaning harder on alcohol, other substances, or more work
  • Doubting your beliefs about safety, justice, or faith
  • A racing heart or trouble catching your breath
47.5%
of lawyers report high or very high work-related burnout (Krill & Anker, 2026)
20.4%
report moderate or higher anxiety symptoms, roughly double the matched 2016 figure (Krill & Anker, 2026)
21.6%
report moderate or higher symptoms of depression (Krill & Anker, 2026)
Rule 1.1
requires competence, and some states now say plainly that a lawyer’s well-being bears on it.
What reduces the exposure
Here are 4 tips to help lower exposure (none takes more than a few minutes).

Each one comes straight from the research above, and each one is something you can do on an ordinary Tuesday without anyone at the firm noticing.

A lawyer at a workshop table, writing in a notebook
1 Watch the load

In the domestic violence study, a heavier load of these clients went with higher secondary traumatic stress and more burnout in all three professions. When the calendar allows, spread the worst material out instead of stacking it into one week, and know which matters on your docket carry the most exposure.

2 Brief and debrief

The gap the study named was supervision for the toll of the work, which therapists and social workers get as part of the job. The military calls its version an after-action review. For a lawyer it can be a ten-minute conversation with a partner, a peer, or a coach before the hardest material and again after it.

3 Use a clinician’s eye

Before you open the photographs or the forensic interview, decide what you’re looking for and why it matters to the case. In the photo study, people who looked at the images that way remembered everything a poker face made others forget.

4 Signal the end of the day

Cortisol takes longest to come down after stress where you’re judged and can’t control the outcome. Give the hardest days a deliberate ending, like a walk or a few minutes of slow breathing before you drive home. Our tactical breathing page has two techniques and the research behind them.

Three terms that get mixed up
Changes what you believe
Vicarious trauma

A gradual shift in how you see the world after long exposure to other people’s trauma, especially your sense of safety, trust, and control (McCann and Pearlman, 1990). It builds over months and years.

Looks like post-traumatic stress
Secondary traumatic stress

Also called compassion fatigue. The intrusion, avoidance, and arousal described above, picked up from other people’s worst experiences instead of your own (Levin and Greisberg, 2003).

Comes from the job itself
Burnout

The World Health Organization defines it as a syndrome “resulting from chronic workplace stress that has not been successfully managed,” marked by exhaustion, cynicism, or distance from the job, and reduced effectiveness (World Health Organization, 2019). Secondary traumatic stress comes from the content of the work, and a lawyer can have both at once.

Confidentiality is part of why lawyers carry this alone.

Although you can’t share the details of a client’s case, you can talk about how the work is affecting you without identifying anyone. Every state also has a free, confidential lawyer assistance program. Find yours on the Lawyer Assistance Map.

Your well-being is part of competent practice.

Under Model Rule 1.1 (Competence), Rule 1.3 (Diligence), and Rule 1.4 (Communication), an attorney’s capacity to practice depends on their mental, emotional, and physical health. A growing number of state bars now make this explicit; Virginia’s amended rules put it plainly: “A lawyer’s mental, emotional, and physical well-being impacts the lawyer’s ability to represent clients.”

Court and legal interpreters carry it too.

Interpreters say the testimony in the first person, often with no team to debrief with afterward. In a survey of 271 public service interpreters in Australia, traumatic material kept affecting 78 percent of them after the assignment ended (Lai, Heydon and Mulayim, 2015). Read what the research shows for interpreters, and what helps.

For firms, courts, and agencies

AWP’s physicians, psychologists, attorneys, and former judges teach this as CLE and work directly with teams that carry the hardest caseloads.

Sources

The research and statistics on this page come from the sources below.

  1. Levin AP, Greisberg S. Vicarious trauma in attorneys. Pace Law Review. 2003;24(1):245. core.ac.uk/download/46712038.pdf The comparison of attorneys at domestic violence and family law agencies with mental health providers and social service workers of similar age and experience. The article reports the differences in words, without score tables.
  2. Levin AP. Secondary trauma and burnout in attorneys: effects of work with clients who are victims of domestic violence and abuse. Undated summary, District of Columbia Courts. dccourts.gov The lead author’s own write-up of the same study, which gives the caseload percentages in the first chart (52%, 28%, and 25% with 21 or more traumatized clients in the past year).
  3. Vrklevski LP, Franklin J. Vicarious trauma: the impact on solicitors of exposure to traumatic material. Traumatology. 2008;14(1):106–118. doi.org/10.1177/1534765607309961 100 solicitors in New South Wales, Australia, 50 in criminal law and 50 in other areas. The chart shows average scores; each pair of bars is drawn against the higher of its two scores because the four measures use different scales. Vicarious trauma, stress, and depression were significantly higher for the criminal lawyers, and satisfaction with work didn’t differ.
  4. Richards JM, Gross JJ. Emotion regulation and memory: the cognitive costs of keeping one’s cool. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 2000;79(3):410–424. doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.79.3.410 The photo experiments behind the poker face finding; suppression hurt people’s ability to describe what they’d seen, and the clinical, detached approach (reappraisal) didn’t.
  5. Gross JJ, Levenson RW. Emotional suppression: physiology, self-report, and expressive behavior. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 1993;64(6):970–986. doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.64.6.970 The film study showing that hiding a reaction raised signs of stress-system activity without making people feel any better.
  6. Dickerson SS, Kemeny ME. Acute stressors and cortisol responses: a theoretical integration and synthesis of laboratory research. Psychological Bulletin. 2004;130(3):355–391. doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.130.3.355 A review of 208 laboratory studies of cortisol, used for the finding on being judged without control over the outcome.
  7. Krill PR, Anker JJ. When demands equal distress: an updated understanding of lawyer mental health and well-being. Journal of Affective Disorders. 2026. doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2026.122479 The burnout, anxiety, and depression figures in the navy band.
  8. McCann IL, Pearlman LA. Vicarious traumatization: a framework for understanding the psychological effects of working with victims. Journal of Traumatic Stress. 1990;3(1):131–149. doi.org/10.1002/jts.2490030110 The original description of vicarious trauma, used for the definition.
  9. World Health Organization. Burn-out an “occupational phenomenon”: International Classification of Diseases. May 28, 2019. who.int The official definition of burnout quoted above.
  10. Lai M, Heydon G, Mulayim S. Vicarious trauma among interpreters. International Journal of Interpreter Education. 2015;7(1). open.clemson.edu/ijie/vol7/iss1/3 The survey of 271 interpreters cited in the interpreter note.

Free to use. Free to share.

There’s no paywall and no sign-up. If it’s useful to your members, your firm, or your colleagues, please pass it along with simple attribution to Attorney Wellness Project.